Rotten Tomatoes
Cancel Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

Maddy Casale

Maddy Casale's reviews only count toward the Tomatometer® when published at Tomatometer-approved publication(s).
Publications:

Reviews

Movies TV Shows
Caught by Love (2026) EDIT “The most unique and engaging thing about Caught by Love is its stunning shots of Malta. Take that away, and there’s not enough emotional honesty, charm, or plot stakes to set this movie apart from other run-of-the-mill rom-coms.” – Decider Jan 27, 2026 Full Review Cosmic Princess Kaguya! (2026) EDIT “While Cosmic Princess Kaguya! is definitely not the most accessible or comprehensible movie for the general viewer, it will likely be a homerun for anyone who falls into its intended target audience.” – Decider Jan 27, 2026 Full Review The Christmas Baby (2025) EDIT “Bolstered by strong writing and performances as well as queer talent both in front of and behind the camera, The Christmas Baby is a heart-warming and entertaining movie you won’t want to miss this holiday season. ” – Decider Dec 23, 2025 Full Review Oy to the World! (2025) EDIT “While the movie definitely has its fair share of schmaltz, Oy to the World! is generally more sweet than cringey, and the actors seemed to have fun making it.” – Decider Dec 17, 2025 Full Review She's Making a List (2025) EDIT “This is a movie that doesn’t bring the cheesy charm and holiday magic you’d hope to see in a Hallmark Christmas movie.” – Decider Dec 8, 2025 Full Review The Night My Dad Saved Christmas 2 (2025) EDIT “The Night My Dad Saved Christmas 2 makes for a very merry viewing experience that is well worth celebrating this holiday season. ” – Decider Dec 8, 2025 Full Review An Alpine Holiday (2025) EDIT “An Alpine Holiday takes viewers on an enchanting and warm-hearted European wintry vacation without you ever needing to splurge on a plane ticket.” – Decider Dec 2, 2025 Full Review Christmas at the Catnip Café (2025) EDIT “ Christmas at the Catnip Café is definitely not a bad movie by any means, but the only things that set it apart or make it memorable compared to other Hallmark movies are the cats.” – Decider Dec 2, 2025 Full Review The Snow Must Go On (2025) EDIT “Corey Cott is a bona fide Broadway performer with a terrific singing voice, and The Snow Must Go On gives him every chance to remind you of this. ” – Decider Dec 2, 2025 Full Review We Met in December (2025) EDIT “Hallmark has created an enjoyable and charming movie in We Met in December, with enough likable characters, meaningful themes, and Christmas magic to make it an easy and entertaining watch this holiday season.” – Decider Dec 2, 2025 Full Review Melt My Heart This Christmas (2025) EDIT “The lackluster attempts at romance and otherwise standard script ultimately ensured that Melt My Heart This Christmas kept my own ticker largely unmoved and unmelted.” – Decider Dec 2, 2025 Full Review Tidings for the Season (2025) EDIT “The actors try their darndest, but their work can’t elevate Tidings for the Season to must-see holiday movie status. ” – Decider Nov 18, 2025 Full Review No Sleep 'Til Christmas (2018) EDIT “Nothing about No Sleep ‘Til Christmas really makes sense, most of all the budding romance between Lizzie and Billy. It’s not charming; it’s toeing the line with cheating, and it’s just not fun to watch. ” – Decider Nov 13, 2025 Full Review A Merry Little Ex-Mas (2025) 56% EDIT “A Merry Little Ex-Mas is a well-made, uncomplicated, cozy Christmas movie bolstered by strong performances, good pacing, and a charming overarching playfulness.” – Decider Nov 13, 2025 Full Review Same Time, Next Christmas (2019) EDIT “It's a pretty good movie to have on in the background of doing something else.” – Decider Nov 13, 2025 Full Review Ghosting: The Spirit of Christmas (2019) EDIT “If you're willing to embrace the full spectrum of human emotion for a bittersweet little story about love and soul mates in all their forms, then Ghosting: The Spirit of Christmas is the movie for you.” – Decider Nov 13, 2025 Full Review Christmas Above the Clouds (2025) EDIT “Christmas Above the Clouds is a pleasant, funny, and creative take on a holiday classic, culminating in a charming film you’d have to be a real Scrooge not to enjoy at least a little bit. ” – Decider Nov 13, 2025 Full Review A Newport Christmas (2025) EDIT “A Newport Christmas is a well-paced, engaging, and feel-good delight.” – Decider Nov 3, 2025 Full Review A Christmas Angel Match (2025) EDIT “This Tender Heart had a great time watching A Christmas Angel Match and thinks you will too.” – Decider Oct 22, 2025 Full Review A Royal Montana Christmas (2025) EDIT “What A Royal Montana Christmas lacks in depth or wow factor, it makes up for in a simple, straightforward viewing experience. ” – Decider Oct 22, 2025 Full Review Adventures in Love & Birding (2025) EDIT “We give Adventures in Love & Birding two wings up for its engaging acting, unique birding plot, and sweet story. ” – Decider Oct 3, 2025 Full Review Same Day with Someone (2025) EDIT “It’s not perfect, it’s not Earth-shattering, but it’s sweet and entertaining, which is more than enough to make it a movie worth watching.” – Decider Sep 23, 2025 Full Review She Said Maybe (2025) EDIT “If you’re hungry for a solid foreign-language film or rom-com title, then the sweet and satisfying German-Turkish delight that is She Said Maybe should satisfy your craving.” – Decider Sep 23, 2025 Full Review The Wrong Paris (2025) 67% EDIT “From the comedy to the acting to the storylines, there’s so much to celebrate and enjoy, making it easy to leave this movie feeling entertained and satisfied. ” – Decider Sep 13, 2025 Full Review Catch of the Day (2025) EDIT “Catch of the Day will make a pleasant, breezy, and surprisingly effective end to your summer streaming with Hallmark.” – Decider Sep 2, 2025 Full Review
No Reviews Yet
Load More