The Prisoner of Second Avenue

Play trailer

The Prisoner of Second Avenue

PG

1975

1h 45m

Comedy

Drama

Play Trailer

Watchlist

Watchlist

Tomatometer

Popcornmeter

52%

Tomatometer

52 Reviews

66%

Popcornmeter

1,000+ Ratings

Neurotic middle-aged New Yorker Mel Edison (Jack Lemmon) is fired from his advertising job, forcing his loving wife, Edna (Anne Bancroft), to become the couple's sole breadwinner. Feeling emasculated, he begins to fall into a depression. A summer heat wave, unthoughtful neighbors and a robbery only worsen matters. When Mel finally suffers a nervous breakdown, he relies on those closest to him, including Edna and his brother Harry (Gene Saks), to restore his sanity.

Critics Consensus

The Prisoner of Second Avenue falters in its translation from stage to screen, with Jack Lemmon's strong portrayal of escalating paranoia overshadowed by forced situational humor.

Read Critics Reviews

Martin Knelman

Globe and Mail

Oct 8

Without the theatricality of the theatre it's easier to notice how hollow the gags are, how contrived the plot, how mechanical the direction.

Go to Full Review

David Robinson

The Times (UK)

05/02/2025

Jack Lemmon is a pastmaster of the Simon style; and Anne Bancroft bats the dialogue back with lovely expertise.

Go to Full Review

Phil Strassberg

Arizona Republic

04/24/2025

It's too grim for most filmgoers to attempt to extract the juicier laugh lines.

Go to Full Review

Charles Brock

Florida Times-Union

Feb 4

Treading on the narrow line of pathos between humor and tragedy, "Prisoner" is a first-rate filmization.

Go to Full Review

Lou Cedrone

Baltimore Sun

Oct 7

Where the stage version was all down, this has up, and the stars are in rare form.

Go to Full Review

David Parkinson

Radio Times

Aug 31

3/5

Working from his own play, Neil Simon unusually fails to strike the right balance between wit and pathos in this strained study of a midlife crisis.

Go to Full Review

Read all reviews

Sal D

@SallyBooks 07/20/2024

A series of uncomfortable arguments between Jack Lemmon and Anne Bancroft, then between his family members, then everybody, then he and his brother, then he and Anne Bancroft again. Often excruciating, always boring.

See more

George L

@RT47615177 04/14/2024

Jack Lemmon and Anne Bancroft are fun to watch. This is a very enjoyable movie

See more

Josh R

@RT27661070 06/20/2020

For roles like this Lemmon deserves Oscar!!! Bravo!

See more

07/12/2018

Wow, just wow. The story of This film is transcendent of generations. Mel and Edna can easily be me and my wife. The hardships of the 70'2 are still the same hardships of today. It is 2018 and this film's plot and characters are still just as relevant as when this movie premiered. As a matter of fact, even the news update snippets sound like snippets of today's society. Neil Simon was and will always be known as a great playwright and his stories (just like Shakespeare's) can be used by any generation. The acting was amazing (loved the chemistry of Jack and Anne), great supporting actors portraying great supporting characters. Melvin Frank's vision for the film was a key to the success of this flm. Recomend this to anyone in their forties no matter what year we are living in.

See more

12/27/2016

'a lessor neil simon' I don't think so and this has the best balance of humour & pathos no ez feat

See more

10/11/2015

Trite and boring. Another waste of time from Doc Neil Simon. I will never understand his appeal. Jack Lemmon and Anne Bancroft could be more irritating. Avoid It.

See more

Read all reviews

Read More

Read Less

WRITE A REVIEW

EDIT REVIEW

POST RATING

Melvin Frank

Director

Jack Lemmon

Mel Edison

Anne Bancroft

Edna Edison

Gene Saks

Harry Edison

Elizabeth Wilson

Pauline

Florence Stanley

Pearl

Every Which Way But Loose

41%

56%

Every Which Way But Loose

Watchlist

Claudine

67%

91%

Claudine

Watchlist

Butterflies Are Free

69%

80%

Butterflies Are Free

Watchlist

Nickelodeon

13%

47%

Nickelodeon

Watchlist

Kotch

75%

68%

Kotch

Watchlist

Discover more movies and TV shows.

View More

View more photos

Synopsis

Neurotic middle-aged New Yorker Mel Edison (Jack Lemmon) is fired from his advertising job, forcing his loving wife, Edna (Anne Bancroft), to become the couple's sole breadwinner. Feeling emasculated, he begins to fall into a depression. A summer heat wave, unthoughtful neighbors and a robbery only worsen matters. When Mel finally suffers a nervous breakdown, he relies on those closest to him, including Edna and his brother Harry (Gene Saks), to restore his sanity.

Director: Melvin Frank
Producer: Melvin Frank
Production Co: Warner Bros.
Rating: PG
Genre: Comedy, Drama
Original Language: English
Release Date (Theaters): Mar 14, 1975, Limited
Release Date (Streaming): Jan 1, 2009
Runtime: 1h 45m