Rotten Tomatoes
Cancel Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes
Critics list

David MacDonald

David MacDonald's reviews only count toward the Tomatometer® when published at Tomatometer-approved publication(s).
Publications:

Reviews

Movies TV Shows
California Suite (1978) 50% EDIT “The first scene is perhaps the worst.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 27, 2020 Full Review Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope (1977) 94% EDIT “If you're out to see a movie with symbolism galore, stay away from Star Wars, but if a memory of that feeling you had at the Saturday matinee as a child is what you want, go stand in line.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 27, 2020 Full Review Outrageous! (1977) 100% EDIT “[Director] Benner brings Outrageous through difficult terrain with admirable results. Gayness is treated naturally, sparing us from those tiring lectures usually found in "gay films." It's all very real, with a delightful mixture of comedy and drama.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 27, 2020 Full Review The Other Side of Midnight (1977) 25% EDIT “When one has to use Valley of the Dolls for comparison, well, you can rest assured that The Other Side of Midnight is not about to become a classic motion picture.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 27, 2020 Full Review Bad (1977) 67% EDIT “Andy Warhol's latest accomplishment, Bad, seems to have proved its point, as long as the point trying to be proven is that Warhol is capable of photographing the most distasteful scenes this side of Pink Flamingos.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 27, 2020 Full Review Julia (1977) 73% EDIT “An exceptional film with my highest regards.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 27, 2020 Full Review Valentino (1977) 46% EDIT “One of the most publicized films of the year has arrived, and believe me, it needs all the publicity it can get, for critical acclaim and public reception is beyond its limited reach.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 27, 2020 Full Review New York, New York (1977) 58% EDIT “If you can sit through 30 interspersed minutes of trivialities, New York, New York emerges victoriously as the musical of the year, and reaffirms Liza Minelli's position as one of the top musical stars, as well as talented actress, on the screen.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 27, 2020 Full Review Voyage of the Damned (1976) 82% EDIT “While the film does have its drawbacks, it is an enlightening look back.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 26, 2020 Full Review A Star Is Born (1976) 37% EDIT “For the most part, A Star Is Born is a dull, indistinguishable remake that reeks with that omni-present Streisand ego.” – Philadelphia Gay News May 26, 2020 Full Review
No Reviews Yet
Load More